I get asked a lot how the different P4P shirt pattterns compare fit wise.
So to help those visual people (most of us sewing/creative types are!), I created a little line drawing with the hourglass figure in each shirt.
Remember, P4P is designed for an hourglass figure; so if you have a different body type you will have a different fit unless you follow your measurements and grade between the sizes you are.
Also, “hips” are the widest part of you- usually your booty. So while looking at the line drawings, remember that the widest part is really the booty!
Here is the quick line drawing:
And for more quick overview here I am in every P4P shirt. I was a solid medium at the time of all pictures unless noted.
Layer Me Up: Tight fit through arms and body meant to be layered under other garments. (Size Medium)
Favorite Fabrics: Knits with lots of stretch (70% more are my favorite) cotton spandex, rayon spandex, and liverpool knit.
Cross my Heart Cami: Fitted through bust and a closefit through waist and hips. This is a medium here.
Favorite Fabrics: Cotton spandex, rayon spandex, jerseys, poly blends, ity, brushed poly and ribbed knit all work well.
The Basic Tee: Fitted through bust and a semi-fit through waist and close at hips. This is a small/medium here.
Favorite Fabrics: Jerseys, tri-blends, double brushed poly, rayon spandex, cotton spandex, poly blends, ity, ribbed knit, sweater knits all work well.
Essential Tank: Fitted through bust and a close semi-fit through waist and hips. This is a medium here.
Favorite Fabrics: Jerseys, rayon spandex, cotton spandex, poly blends, ity and ribbed knit all work well.
Women’s Henley: Fitted through bust and semi-fitted through waist and hips. (I don’t have many of these since it was drafted and released when I was pregnant 🙂 I made a medium here, but my bust and waist were bigger right after baby girl arrived!)
Favorite Fabrics: thermals, medium weight sweater knits, cotton jerseys, and rayon spandex.
Boyfriend V Neck: Semi-fitted through bust, waist and hips. (Size Medium)
Favorite Fabrics: I like to use a cotton jersey, interlock, medium weight sweater knit for a more fitted look. For a looser/slub feel I go for rayon spandex.
Slim Fit Raglan: Fitted at bust and arms, semi-fitted at waist and hips.
Favorite Fabrics: Medium weight sweater knit, rayon spandex blends, cotton spandex, stretch french terry, slub jersey.
Women’s Raglan: Loose fit through bust and waist, semi-fitted at hips- straight cut. Loose on arms. (Size Medium)
Favorite Fabrics: More stable knits like french terry, sweatshirt, fleece, interlock, and ponte roma.
(PS- I have a light pink undershirt under the lace one! I didn’t realize that was a mistake until after the pictures! lol)
Favorite Tee: this is fitted at bust and semi-fitted through waist and hip. The side vent hem can give you even more relaxed fit through hip.
Favorite Fabics: You have a pretty wide range of knits you can use on this shirt. I prefer a flowly, drapey knit for the curved hem option like rayon spandex, modal, poly jerseys, ITY. For the banded hem option I love something with a little more structure like a rayon french terry and poly jerseys. The side vent hem can use either of these and look great. For the dress length I prefer something more structured again like double brushed poly, cotton spandex, rayon french terry.
Sweet Tee: this is a slimmed dolman with very small “bat wings” under the arms. It is fitted at bust and semi-fitted through waist and hips.
Favorite Fabics: light to medium weight knits, although it has very small “bat wings” I still strongly prefer a soft drape for any dolman so that your “wings” aren’t puffy 😉 I used tissue jersey, slub jersey, light and medium weight sweater knits, and rayon spandex for my favorites.
Tulip Tee: this is a boxy, relaxed fit dolman. Semi-fitted at bust and hip, but a straighter cut through waist. Although it’s not straight, it is still very loose through waist. The plain option will feel and fit tighter at the waist and hip than the tulip option, which will naturally swing open for a looser feel.
Favorite Fabics: light to medium weight knits. I prefer a soft drape for any dolman so that your “wings” aren’t puffy 😉 I used mostly rayon/modal/ blends for mine personally. I love it in a soft sweater knit for fall/winter as well. You could use a slub knit, poly blend, triblend, ITY all as well.
Pumpkin Spice Dolman: oversized/loose fit through upper arms, bust and waist. Semi-fitted on hips. Tight fit on lower arms. (Medium in the navy/grey and Large in the others- I hit those measurements at the time of sewing/pictures :))
Favorite Fabrics: I like fabric with good drape for this one. Rayon spandex blends, sweater knits (both medium and lighter work), thinner slub jerseys, french terry with rayon in the blend, and ity.
Free Spirit Tank: Fitted at bust, drastic a-line out to give loose fit through waist and hips. (Size Medium)
Favorite Fabrics: I like fabric with good stretch and drape for this one. Rayon spandex blends, sweater knits and thinner slub jersey.
Sporty Piko: A very loose, straight cut from the short sleeve juncture. It is loose throughout the body with relaxed sleeves as well.
Favorite Fabrics: It really depends on the look you’re wanting for this one! I love a french terry for the hoodie options, but for an everyday tee it must have a very soft drape. You can use various fabrics depending on how boxy you want the shirt to appear- the more stable the fabric the boxier it will look worn.
Brunch Blouse: Fitted at bust, curves in only a touch at waist, loose on hips.
Favorite Fabrics: Rayon challis, crepe, anything with a softer drape.
Everyday Elegance: Loose fit through bust and waist- straight cut to hips. (Size Medium)
Favorite Fabrics: I like fabrics with lots of drape for this one like peach skin, chiffon, rayon challis.
Amanda says
This is going to be helpful to so many!!
patternsforpirates says
Thank you! It’s been on the list of things to do for a long time now! So glad to get it done! 🙂
Val says
Thanks for the comparisons Judy, they are very helpful.
Val.
patternsforpirates says
Thank you!
kc says
Thank you for the comparisons. You are absolutely stunning!
patternsforpirates says
Thank you so much!
Tootie says
Thank you for the comparisons! This really helps! I love all your patterns!!
patternsforpirates says
Thank you! It’s been on the list of things to do for a long time now! So glad to get it done! 🙂